Bill O'Reilly & Maureen McPhilmy Divorce
A divorce that exposed how a powerful media figure allegedly weaponized custody arbitration against his ex-wife.
Key Facts
What Happened
Bill O'Reilly, then the top-rated host on Fox News, and Maureen McPhilmy finalized their divorce on September 1, 2011, after 15 years of marriage. The settlement, reportedly around $10 million, seemed straightforward enough. The couple agreed to share equal custody of their two children on a week-on, week-off basis. They also agreed to resolve any future custody disputes through a supposedly neutral social worker named Lynne Kulakowski.
What followed was anything but neutral. McPhilmy discovered that O'Reilly had hired Kulakowski as his children's full-time nanny, effectively placing the supposedly impartial arbitrator on his payroll. A court later found that Kulakowski was performing virtually all of O'Reilly's parental duties during his custody weeks, raising serious questions about the integrity of the arbitration arrangement.
McPhilmy moved to modify the custody agreement just one month after the divorce was finalized. The legal battle stretched on for years. In 2015, a Nassau County Supreme Court justice ruled that McPhilmy should be granted sole custody of the children, a devastating blow to O'Reilly. In a separate proceeding, McPhilmy was fined $310,000 for violating the custody agreement, illustrating how both sides suffered in the prolonged conflict.
O'Reilly later sued McPhilmy for $10 million, alleging she had manipulated the separation agreement and committed adultery. The case became a cautionary tale about how arbitration clauses in divorce agreements can be exploited, and why the selection of neutral third parties requires extraordinary care.
Legal Breakdown: When arbitration becomes manipulation in custody disputes
Corrupted Arbitration Process
The O'Reilly divorce revealed the danger of arbitration clauses when one party has disproportionate resources. By hiring the supposedly neutral social worker as his nanny, O'Reilly effectively undermined the entire dispute resolution framework built into the divorce agreement.
Custody Modification After Finalization
Divorce is never truly final when children are involved. McPhilmy moved to modify custody just one month after the divorce was finalized, and the court ultimately reversed the original arrangement entirely. Parents should understand that custody orders can always be modified if circumstances warrant.
Post-Divorce Litigation as Warfare
O'Reilly's $10 million lawsuit against McPhilmy, and her $310,000 fine for custody violations, illustrate how divorce proceedings can continue for years after the decree is signed. Both parties suffered financial and emotional costs from ongoing litigation.
What This Means for Your Divorce
- →Always vet the neutrality of any mediator or arbitrator named in a divorce agreement, and build in safeguards against conflicts of interest.
- →Custody arrangements can be modified post-divorce if one parent demonstrates changed circumstances or manipulation.
- →High-powered spouses may use their resources to tilt supposedly fair processes; document everything and seek independent legal counsel.
- →Post-divorce lawsuits can become a financial and emotional drain for both parties, sometimes costing more than the original settlement.
Going Through a Divorce?
Get confidential guidance tailored to your situation — free, private, and available 24/7.
Related Cases
Brad Pitt & Angelina Jolie
United States · 2016–present
8+ years of custody battles — and still no final resolution
Custody & ChildrenArnold Schwarzenegger & Maria Shriver
United States · 2011–2021
A secret child with the housekeeper, a Kennedy family dynasty, and a 10-year divorce saga
Custody & ChildrenKim Basinger & Alec Baldwin
United States · 2002
A custody battle so brutal that Baldwin wrote a book about it — and a leaked voicemail shocked the nation
Custody & ChildrenWas this helpful? Help us keep it free.
divorce911.ai is funded entirely by donations. Every dollar keeps the AI assistant and 1,700+ guides free for people in crisis.
Know someone going through a divorce? This could help them.
This article is based on publicly available court records, news reports, and legal analysis. It is provided for educational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. No attorney-client relationship is created by reading this content.
Divorce laws vary by jurisdiction. Always consult a licensed attorney in your area before making legal decisions.